Home / Weed identification / Plumeless Thistle
US weed ID · Pasture & rangeland weed
Plumeless Thistle
Carduus acanthoides · Asteraceae (aster family)
- Biennial
- Thistle
- Non-native
A spiny, much-branched thistle covered with narrow, deeply cut leaves and small purple flowers on spiny-winged stalks is probably plumeless thistle.
How to get rid of itAll weeds A–Z
What is plumeless thistle?
Plumeless thistle is a spiny biennial from Eurasia that has spread through pastures, prairies and roadsides across much of the central United States. plumeless thistle identification hinges on a few features: narrow, deeply divided leaves; small, upright flower heads; and spiny wings that run up the flower stalks right to the base of each head.
Grazing animals steer around its spines and eat the plants beside it, which gives the thistle an edge in pastures every year. Dense stands compete with grass for water and nutrients and cut the forage available to livestock, wildlife and people using the land. Each plant can shed up to 10,000 seeds that survive in the soil for over a decade, so a patch left alone gets worse fast. Nebraska alone has about 45,000 infested acres.
Plumeless Thistle identification: what to look for
Look at the flower stalks first. On plumeless thistle the spiny leaf wings continue right up to the flower head, which is a reliable field mark. Then check the underside of a leaf for hairs and compare the flower size with musk thistle, its closest look-alike.
- Leaves: Deeply and irregularly divided almost to the midrib, with spiny lobes; dark green with a lighter midrib and hairy underneath. Stem leaves run about 4 to 8 inches long.
- Stems: Freely branching near the top, with continuous spiny wings that extend up the flower stalks.
- Flower heads: Purple, upright, roughly 1/2 to 1 inch across, single or in small clusters at branch tips.
- Bracts: Several rows of bracts under each head; the outer ones are spine-tipped and the inner ones are soft.
- Rosette: First-year rosette leaves are divided into spine-tipped lobes, a bit less deeply cut and less hairy on top than the later stem leaves.
- Seeds: Light brown, slightly curved, about 1/8 inch long, with a ring of fine bristles.
Where it grows in the United States
Plumeless thistle is most common in the east-central Great Plains, with scattered populations farther west. States reporting it include Nebraska, the Dakotas, Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas, Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri, Montana, Wyoming, Colorado and New Mexico, and it is regulated in Wisconsin as well. It was first found in Nebraska in 1930.
It typically starts on low-quality, disturbed ground such as roadsides, ditch banks and old fields, then moves into pastures, meadows and even high-quality prairie. It is rarely a problem in spring-planted cropland, but it can infest no-till fields and fall-seeded crops, where it may ripen seed before harvest.
Plumeless Thistle look-alikes
A few plants get mixed up with it:
- Musk thistle (Carduus nutans): Flower heads are much larger (about 1.5 to 3 inches), usually single and slightly nodding, and its leaves are hairless and less deeply cut. Plumeless thistle has small upright heads, hairy leaf undersides and spiny wings right to the heads.
- Scotch thistle (Onopordum acanthium): Covered in dense wool, so the whole plant looks bluish or grayish green. Plumeless thistle is dark green and far less woolly.
How to get rid of plumeless thistle
Pulling, digging and mowing: For a few plants, cut each one off 1 to 2 inches below the soil line with a sharp shovel before it flowers. Mowing keeps seed from forming that year, but younger plants keep bolting, so mow second-year plants twice a season: once at early bud and again just before flowering. Bag any cut flower heads. Because buried seed keeps sprouting, check the site every year and treat new plants as they appear.
Cultural control matters most, because the right conditions keep it from coming back.
- Fertilize grass and avoid overgrazing; Nebraska calls a well-managed, healthy grassland the most cost-effective control.
- Combine two or more methods rather than relying on herbicide alone.
- Biological control insects released for musk thistle also attack plumeless thistle; they work slowly, only supplement other methods, and in Nebraska must be approved by the local weed authority.
- Scout pastures, roadsides and ditches every year, since seed can wait in the soil for more than a decade.
Herbicides: Rosettes are the easiest target. Wisconsin DNR suggests spot-spraying rosettes in fall with an ester form of 2,4-D, or using clopyralid or metsulfuron-methyl as foliar sprays. Spot treatment uses less herbicide and spares nearby native plants; broadcast spraying is for large, dense infestations. Pick a product labeled for your site, whether pasture, rangeland, roadside or lawn, and follow the label, which is the law. If you hire someone to spray, make sure they hold your state’s pesticide applicator license; the rules for each state are in our pesticide applicator license guide.
Keeping it from coming back
Keep seed out: buy clean hay and seed, clean mowers and equipment after working in thistle, and don't let a single plant flower on your property. Watch roadsides, ditches and field edges, where infestations usually start.
A thick, well-fertilized grass stand that isn't grazed short is the best long-term defense. Because seed persists for years, plan on watching cleaned-up areas and removing new rosettes for several seasons.
Questions we get about plumeless thistle
What's the difference between plumeless thistle and musk thistle?
Musk thistle has large, single, nodding flowers 1.5 to 3 inches wide and hairless leaves. Plumeless thistle has small upright flowers about an inch wide or less, hairy leaf undersides and spiny wings all the way to the flower.
Is plumeless thistle a noxious weed?
In many states, yes, including Nebraska, Colorado, Minnesota and Wisconsin. It is not on the federal noxious weed list.
When should I spray plumeless thistle?
At the rosette stage, ideally in fall, before plants bolt and flower.
How long do plumeless thistle seeds last?
More than ten years in the soil, so follow-up for several years is part of the job.
Weeds taking over a bed, slope or wet spot?
In central Pennsylvania, Muthler rebuilds beds, regrades and drains wet ground, clears overgrown brush and builds patios and walls across Clinton, Lycoming, Centre and Union counties. Outside central PA? Groundwork Single Space ($349) is a scaled 2D plan of one area with plants matched to your hardiness zone, designed remotely.
Get a free estimateSee landscape designSimilar weeds
Sources: USDA PLANTS: Carduus acanthoides (spiny plumeless thistle) · USDA APHIS: Federal Noxious Weed List · Nebraska Department of Agriculture: Plumeless Thistle · Wisconsin DNR: Plumeless Thistle · Minnesota Department of Agriculture: Minnesota Noxious Weed List · Colorado Department of Agriculture: Noxious Weed Species · Oregon Department of Agriculture: Noxious Weed Policy and Classification System (Oregon noxious weed list) · Utah Department of Agriculture and Food: State of Utah Noxious Weed List
Herbicides: always read and follow the product label. Pesticide applicator licensing rules vary by state.




